Harris County to provide public defenders at bail hearings

Harris Co Bail

Harris County commissioners today voted unanimously to provide public defenders at bail hearings.

Two public defenders will be present at hearings where hearing officers set bail for criminal defendants, a process officials say results in the unnecessary jailing of thousands of defendants because they can’t afford bail or are unfamiliar with the legal process.

The pilot program approved Tuesday is part of the county’s effort to reform its criminal justice system that has come under intense scrutiny in recent years.

A federal civil rights lawsuit alleges the county’s bail system violates the rights of poor people by enforcing a rigid bail schedule that does not take into account that many poor people facing misdemeanor charges cannot make even nominal bail payments.

“It’s going in the right direction,” said Harris County judge Ed Emmett. “This is one of those things we needed to do.”

This story originally appeared 3/14/2017 in the Houston Chronicle.

People In Houston Are No Longer Going To Jail For Marijuana Possession


Beginning on Wednesday, people who are caught with small amounts of marijuana in Harris County, Texas, will no longer earn a trip to jail.

Under the new policy, announced last month, police in Texas’ most populous county will instead offer four-hour drug education classes to anybody found with less than four ounces of marijuana. Harris County includes Houston, the fourth-most populous city in the U.S., with about 4.5 million residents.

Authorities will still arrest and prosecute cases when they find marijuana in school zones or in conjunction with other criminal behavior, and juveniles are not eligible for the program. But most low-level marijuana offenders will now avoid a trip to police station, won’t get booked into jail and won’t get a criminal record, as long as they complete the drug education course.

The classes cost $150, and financial aid will be available to people unable to pay. The county will pursue charges against those who fail to attend.

Officials say the new approach will save $26 million annually by lifting costs related to law enforcement, incarceration and the court system.

“When you have 10,000 cases on a 100,000-plus case docket that are simple marijuana possession cases, you look for smart ways to resolve those so that you can dedicate your resources to the really serious crimes,” Tom Berg, Harris County’s first assistant district attorney, told The Huffington Post.

The new policy will also mitigate costs that can pile up as defendants are caught in the legal system.

“Defendants don’t miss work, they don’t go to jail, they don’t have to make bonds, they don’t have to pay lawyers, the courts are not congested with these cases and the jail is less crowded,” Berg said.

The change comes as newly elected leaders in Harris County usher in a broader criminal justice reform agenda. District Attorney Kim Ogg and Sheriff Ed Gonzalez, both Democrats, campaigned on overhauling ineffective tough-on-crime policies and won their elections by substantial margins in November. Gonzalez and newly minted Houston Police Chief Art Acevedo, along with Houston’s Democratic mayor, Sylvester Turner, have expressed support for the new policy.

Harris County, an ethnically diverse and politically purple bastion in deep-red Texas, has previously taken a more lenient stance on weed than many of its neighbors. In 2015, then-District Attorney Devon Anderson, a Republican, announced a policy intended to divert nonviolent first-time marijuana offenders found with less than two ounces of marijuana to treatment.

But a report last year found that in the first six months of 2016, officers in Harris County had made more than 1,000 arrests involving people with less than two ounces of pot, 98 percent of them people in poorer communities.

Small-time marijuana charges still appear to be disrupting people’s lives. The Texas Organizing Project, a nonprofit that promotes social and economic equality, published a video last year that showed Harris County court magistrates making harsh assessments against defendants facing relatively minor charges.

In one clip involving a woman arrested for a misdemeanor marijuana charge, a judge doubles her bail from $1,000 to $2,000 after she responds to the judge’s question by saying “yeah” instead of “yes.” The woman has to remain in jail until the conclusion of her trial unless she comes up with $2,000, or a portion of it, to pay a commercial bail bondsman.

Harris County’s new marijuana program shows how activists can promote criminal justice reform through local elections, says Tarsha Jackson, Harris County director of the Texas Organizing Project. Her group and other civil rights organizations in the Houston area supported Ogg and Gonzalez in November.

“We’ve had the same administration here for over 40 years, and crime has not decreased based on being tough on crime, it’s only increased,” said Jackson. “Now we’re bringing in a fresh set of minds that are looking at crime a different way ― not targeting low-level offenses or oppressed black and brown communities.”

“If it can happen in Harris County, it can happen anywhere,” she added.

Local leaders’ reform-minded approach has also invited criticism from other officials in Texas, where police across the state made 70,000 arrests for marijuana possession in 2013, according to FBI data.

Last month, Brett Ligon, the Republican district attorney in neighboring Montgomery County, assailed Ogg, saying her plan would make Harris County “a sanctuary for dope smokers.” Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick (R) has since employed identical language in his criticism of Ogg.

Berg says these attacks are motivated more by politics than policy, and are examples of GOP officials pushing back against progressive victories in Texas.

“[District Attorney Ogg] is being responsive to the people who elected her,” said Berg. “The political message from Republicans is different from actual criticism of the policy.”

Supporters of draconian drug enforcement tactics may find themselves increasingly at odds with their constituents. Polling last month found that 83 percent of Texans now support legalizing marijuana for some use, while 53 percent support legalizing weed for any use.

Houston City Council Member Dwight Boykins has been one of the most vocal supporters of the county’s new marijuana program. He launched a “2nd Chance” job fair to increase employment opportunities for ex-offenders, and believes too many people are getting funneled into the criminal justice system. Boykins says it’s a human rights issue, not a political one.

“We all make mistakes, but by the grace of God, a lot of us just didn’t get caught,” he said. “You can’t turn your back on people because of a mistake they made in bad judgment.”

This story originally appeared 3/1/2017 in The Huffington Post.

Harris County sued again over alleged civil rights violations


Harris County has been sued in federal court for the third time in less than a year for yet another issue related to the county’s tough arrest and pretrial detention practices.

This time, civil rights advocates allege that county officials routinely charge and jail thousands of people each month without a warrant and without ever requiring police officers to supply sworn statements that adequately describe the crimes for which the defendants stand accused, according to a lawsuit filed Wednesday in the Southern District of Texas.

The plaintiffs were arrested and jailed over the Christmas holidays for non-violent offenses.

Lucas Lomas, 26, of Pasadena, was arrested Christmas Eve for allegedly pilfering five DVDs and a speaker, according to a document prepared by a prosecutor and co-signed by an officer. The filing provides no details about how the arresting officer determined Lomas had stolen the items. After a video hearing that is typical in Harris County, a hearing officer found probable cause to proceed with charges. Lomas was released after posting $15,000 bail.

Carlos Eaglin, 27, of Houston, was arrested Dec. 26 for alleged possession of less than two ounces of marijuana. Court papers co-signed by an officer and prosecutor accuse Eaglin of marijuana possession, but do not include a statement from the officer about how the substance was discovered or determined to be marijuana. After his video hearing, Eaglin was jailed on a $5,000 bond – the highest amount specified for any misdemeanor in Harris County’s so-called bond schedule. He remains in jail.

The lawsuit, filed by the Texas Fair Defense Project and by the Washington D.C.-based Civil Rights Corps, seeks to compel the county to provide all people arrested with a more detailed statement of facts under oath from a police officer that is consistent with both state and federal law. Those documents then could be reviewed by what the case describes as a “neutral magistrate.”

First Assistant County Attorney Robert Soard said Wednesday that county officials were still studying the allegations and preparing a response to the case.

As of Jan. 1, incoming Harris County District Attorney Kim Ogg will be overseeing the prosecuting attorneys who handle the intake process for both felony and misdemeanor cases. Ogg, who is not named in the lawsuit, was not immediately available for comment Thursday.

The Civil Rights Corps and other groups previously sued the City of Houston and Harris County over other violations of the rights of criminal defendants.

Houston officials have been sued over increasing delays in the time between arrests and the time city criminal defendants first see a judge.

Harris County faces a more complex civil rights challenge to the way the county’s misdemeanor judges and hearing officers set bonds for defendants accused of minor crimes – a system that has resulted in long pretrial detention, jail overcrowding and a higher conviction rate for poor people who can’t afford bail.

All three lawsuits remain pending.

This story originally appeared 12/29/2016 in the Houston Chronicle.